This is Part VII of a blog series for employers to avoid audit by ICE. After the employer receives a notice from ICE, which details whether the employer has been found in violation, then ICE will determine the employer‘s penalties.
The following are the most common notices:
• Notice of Inspection Results
• Notice of Suspect Documents
• Notice of Discrepancies
• Notice of Technical or Procedural Failures
• Warning Notice
• Notice of Intent to Fine
• Final Order
• Notice of Hearing
• Determination of Recommended Fine
Find that each type of notice is hyperlinked and explained in further detail.
There are three different types of violations that an employer could be found guilty of: civil fines and criminal penalties for violation for Form I-9 laws; ‘knowing hire’ and ‘continuing to employ’ violations; and substantive and uncorrected technical violations.
Employers who have ‘knowingly hire’ or ‘continuing to employ’ violations will be forced to stop unlawful activity and may be fined. ICE will divide the number of both violations by the number of employees with misfiled Forms I-9, and obtain a violation percentage.
The violation percentage gives a base fine amount depending on whether this is a First Tier (first time violator), Second Tier (second time violator), or Third Tier (third time violator) case.
In our very own city, St. Louis, J&J Industrial Supply, Inc. was found at fault for employing illegal workers after an inspection by ICE‘s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI). The company pled guilty to knowingly hiring multiple illegal immigrants, and was charged with a $150,000 penalty, a year of probation, and forfeiting a company car. The monetary fine was equal to the profit J&J made during the 12-month period that illegal immigrants were on the company payroll.
J&J Industrial Supply was initially caught because a driver of the (forfeited) company car was caught speeding. The car was pulled over by the police and found that an illegal alien employee was driving. ICE was immediately called. Under Missouri Statute 577.675.1, it is “unlawful for any person to knowingly transport, move, or attempt to transport in the state of Missouri any illegal alien who is not lawfully present in the United States…for purposes of employment.” Doing so will result in prison time, a monetary fine, or both.
In another midwest town, Springfield, IL, five employees from La Fiesta Mexican Restaurant were criminally charged. Three were charged with abuse of fraudulent employment eligibility records; the other two were charged with illegally reentering the US after having been previously deported. If found guilty, the penalty for misusing false documents is up to five years in prison; the penalty for reentering the US after deportation is 20 years in prison and a $250,000 fine. Not only will the unauthorized workers be charged, but the owners can also be charged in civil and criminal indictments, and are also liable to fines.
In San Diego, California, The French Gourmet, Inc. was sentenced for charges of knowingly hiring illegal workers after a four year inspection by ICE‘s HSI. The company was ordered to forfeit $109,200 in profits made during the year in which illegal workers were employed, and ordered to pay $277,375 for its employment of illegal aliens. The company’s owner was also sentenced to five years of probation based on these ‘knowingly hiring’ violations.
Click on the different types of violations, which are hyperlinked, to find charts of employment percentages and fines.
Next Week : Part VIII: How can employers protect themselves from discrimination?
Part IX: Best Practices
Part X: Managing I-9 in Mergers and Acquisitions
Part XI: Correcting I-9
Part XII: Storing/Retaining I-9
See you in my next blog.
Nalini S Mahadevan, JD, MBA
Attorney at Law
Copyright 2012. All rights reserved.
Post Footer automatically generated by Add Post Footer Plugin for wordpress.by